Cut Out Sugar, or Cut Out Fat – Turns Out, Both Approaches Are Wrong - ig2go

Cut Out Sugar, or Cut Out Fat – Turns Out, Both Approaches Are Wrong

by Linda Baldwin
.
March 18, 2014

Dangers of Non-Fat diets

Researchers love twin experiments because health is so heavily determined by genetics. However, nutrition and exercise also significantly affect health, which is why this recent month-long twin experiment in Britain is so interesting.

Two brothers, twins Chris and Xand, who are both physicians with similar lifestyles and identical fitness regimens, decided to test which nutrient was worse for you: Sugar or fat. The no-sugar, or ultra-low-fat diets are fairly common approaches to weight loss, but it turns out neither are the best method for pursuing a healthy lifestyle. Well I could have told them that!

Low-Fat

Chris adopted the low-fat diet, allocating the bare minimum of 2 percent of his daily total intake to fat. Essentially, he mimicked the “Non-Fat” craze that took over much of the diet market in the 1990’s. Interestingly, in the late 1980’s, two major reports came out identifying dietary fat as the most important change to improving health, which resulted in food manufacturers substituting sugar for fat (ie. Snackwell cookies).

As many 90’s dieters (and Chris) discovered, severely reducing fat does not lead to losing weight. The Low-fat dieting twin experienced constant feelings of hunger, which made him eat more in calories despite the low fat count.

Sugar-Free

Xand, the other twin, went for a high protein diet that eliminated carbohydrates – not just table sugar, but also flour and fruit which convert to sugar – similar to the Atkins diet. When the Dr. Atkins Diet Revolution was first published in 1972, the President of the American College of Nutrition was quoted as saying “Of all the bizarre diets that have been proposed in the last 50 years, this is the most dangerous to the public if followed for any length of time.”

Xand discovered that eliminating all sugar had some nasty side effects, including less energy and stamina, bad breath, constipation, and fatigue. He did lose more weight (a total of 9 pounds in the course of the month), but he said the low-carb, high-protein diet caused his body to go into ketosis (the body burns fat, but doesn’t provide enough glucose to the brain). Ketosis can also lead to kidney failure.

And The Winner Is?

So which is better: No sugar, or Low-fat? It turns out, both are “pretty miserable” in the words of the brothers.

Their conclusion, according to Chris, was “We should not vilify a single nutrient.” The twin doctors reportedly decided that it’s the combination of sugar and fat found in many processed foods that is the real source of diet-related problems. They recommend watching calories and portion size while eating mostly whole foods. The experiment might be news, but the conclusion sounds like common sense to me!

Share this Article

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Category
Tags
acai bowls acne diet adrenal fatigue adrenal glands aging alkaline diets all natural anti-inflammatory antioxidants aphrodesiac foods aphrodisiacs apple recipes apples arthritis artificial sweeteners aspartame Atkins Autism auto immune Balanced Diet be grateful beauty best foods for skin big food corporations BMI bone broth bpa in plastic brain chemistry brain foods brain foods bread breville juicer Broccoli broth brushing skin brussels sprouts brussels sprouts recipes burdock root cacao health benefits Calcium Camel Milk cancer cure Cancer Fighters cauliflower Cauliflower Colcannon causing cancer chemicals in our food Chia Recipes choclate cake Christmas chronic fatigue Clean Eating coconut oil coconut water Cold Remedies cold season cold-fighting superfoods collagen, conscious eating cookie monster Cruciferous Vegetables dairy-free dandelion greens december Delicious Delivery Dessert Detoxing dewey complextion dewier complexions, Diabetes Diet and Exercise diet myths Diets draining lymph Drinks easy fall salads easy healthy food easy juice cleanse eat clean eating local Ethnic Foods Excercise exfoliating fall recipes fall salad recipes Fall superfoods families Fast Food fat free fat sick and nearly dead Fathers Day Menu Fatigue feel good foods fig recipes Fighting colds Fish fitness myths Flexitarianism Florida Florida Superfoods flu flu fighting foods food Food Energetics Food Gift Ideas food matters food myths food pyramid food sources of iron food storage food to reduce stress foods for adrenal fatigue Foods for Anxiety foods for colds Foods for Depression foods for flu foods that help your brain foods to boost sex drive fourth of july recipes Fresh Herbs Fruit Popsicles Fruit Smoothies fruits and vegetables Fun Glucosemine Gluten Free gluten free brownie gluten-free recipes glycemic index GMO goji berries good fats good for you good mood foods gourmet Great Food that's Great for you green bean casserole recipe Green Juice Green Tea growing heirloom tomatoes from seed growing quinoa halloween party treats healing Healing with Food healing yourself with juice Health health benefits of blueberries health benefits of broccoli health benefits of coconut water health benefits of eggs health benefits of figs health benefits of mushrooms health benefits of pumpkin health benefits of pumpkin pie health benefits of summer squash health benefits of sweet potatoes health food health food myths Health Food Studies health stories in the news healthy healthy appetizer recipes healthy appetizers healthy cookies healthy desserts healthy drinks recipes healthy during the holidays healthy eating healthy fall recipes healthy food healthy fourth of july recipes healthy green bean casserole healthy halloween treats healthy holiday baking healthy holiday cookies Healthy Holiday Desserts Healthy Holiday Party Recipes healthy ingredients Healthy Irish Food Healthy Irish Recipes healthy kids food healthy oils healthy party recipes Healthy Popsicles Healthy St. Patrick's Day healthy thanksgiving recipes healthy thanksgiving side dishes Heart heart disease heart health heart healthy eating heart-healthy foods Herbal Tea herbs high energy high fiber foods holiday baking holiday cookies holiday dinner Holiday Recipes Holiday Superfoods holidays holistic health Hormones how to correct insulin resistance how to prevent insulin resistance hype vs healthy foods Ice Cream immune system immune system boosters immunity inflammation insulin resistance insulin resistance and exercise intelligent gourmet Intuitive Eating Iodine joint pain juice juice cleanse Juice Detox juice fast juice pulp Juice Recipes juice shop juices juicing juicing for health juicing in tampa juicing or blending Kids lemon peels life by daily burn lingonberries losing weight low fat low fat thanksgiving recipes low glycemic foods Low in sodium low-carb recipes low-fat gravy recipe low-fat lunch low-fat recipes low-glycemic diet mama nature meatballs medicinal juicing memory Mental Wellbeing Move Inspired Health & Fitness natural aversion natural flavors natural healing natural medicine Natural Remedies naturally made new year new you new year's resolution New Year's Resolutions New Years niman ranch Non Fat Diet non-fat november Nutrition nutritional coaching Nuts oils omega 3 omega 3 skin organic organic produce ph balance plastic microwave pms popcorn recipes practice preservatives preventing acne with omega 3 Probiotics promotes relaxations pumpkin pumpkin butter pumpkin butter recipe pumpkin healthy pumpkin recipes quinoa raw food raw vegan lasagna recipe raw vegan recipes recipes resolutions restful sleep rituals roasted salad safe to heat plastic in microwave salads sandwiches sea beans seasonal seasonal recipes seasonal vegetables selenium selfcare skin foods skincare diet Smoothie Recipies Smoothies sodium nitrites in food sometimes food Soup soup recipes spices spoiling food and cosmetics spring cleanses spring florida spring fruits Spring Superfoods spring vegetables stevia stress busting foods stress eating stress food Stress-Busting Superfoods substances in your food sugar bomb Sugar Free Diet summer Summer Party Foods summer superfoods super-foods superfood pairings superfoods Superfoods for Dad Sushi Tampa tampeaeats Tea Tea Health Benefits thanksgiving thanksgiving dinner thanksgiving recipes thanksgiving turkey recipe things to practice daily thyroid foods trustworthy sources turkey brine recipe turmeric turmeric root Valentine's Day vanilla health properties vegan Vegan Diet Vegan Food Tampa Bay vegan soup recipes vegan tampa vegetarian Vegetarian Side Dishes vitamin d vitamins walnuts water watermelon watermelon health properties Weight weight loss weight loss superfoods wellness whole food Whole Foods why eat seasonal why organic is healthier will-power winter soups workout Yogurt zucchini noodles
Archives